This post has existed, in my head and on my dash, for quite some time. It is one that has both been difficult to pen and important to write.
American politics has two parties – Democrats and Republicans. Everyone else is an Independent. In this day in age, Democrats are willy-nilly spenders who want to abolish religion, take your guns and force birth control on your four year old while Republicans are gun-toting, Bible belt, backwoods , bad spellers who want to ensure vanilla marriage is always protected. For Americans, whether or not they know it, “Independent” has become the new “Middle Class”. It’s the moniker assigned to everyone, not by their beliefs, their values or their government but by themselves. It is, in short, the epitome not of reasoned responses but of mediocrity and compromise. It isn’t the rational choice, it’s the socially acceptable way to avoid making one.
Still, at the same time, our own political system is fracturing further. Republicans break into the Tea Party (read: people who don’t like taxes) and Social Conservatives (read: religious people.) Democrats faction into Progressives (read: conspiracy theorists), Libertarians (read: constitutional purists, except for women and African-Americans) and your basic Liberal (read: pinko-communists).
I grew up in a pro-Choice household that owned guns (though they were fairly uninteresting to 75% of us). My parents were small business owners. My mother identifies as bi-sexual and studied theology in college with the intention of becoming a minister in the Lutheran church. (These things actually happened in the opposite order ;P) They both grew up in a rural area. My mother is the child of an underemployed German-Irish alcoholic and a devoutly Christian mother. My father was raised by an over employed German-Irish alcoholic and a WASP of a mother. Both of my grandfathers came from that which most of the German-Irish did back then – nothing. I was raised in private schools with the children of doctors, lawyers, dentists and politicians, yet my teachers had a heavy investment in social issues and raised us carefully.
In short, I received what is either the most well-rounded political upbringing, or the most chaotic.
For myself, I am extremely well educated and have been gifted with a brilliant mind (and humility too!) I am female. I’ve been patted on the head and called precocious by what I’m certain will become Presidential candidates in the next 10 years. At least once or twice a year, I receive a personal phone call from a Senator asking a question about an e-mail or a letter I wrote on behalf of a cause or an organization I believe in. I read bills. I watch C-SPAN. I do my best to engage even the un-engagable in our political process, even if it is only to bend them to my will. I vote with all of the fervor demanded by such a sacred duty. I read books. I think. I absorb information. I have a small, rubber globe I periodically throw at my television during floor fights and Presidential debates.
Politically, I believe in pulling yourself up by your bootstraps, but I also believe in not cutting people off at the knees. I believe that the US government, if no where else on earth, should be aspirational – should be about hope. I believe that every child, regardless of their societal birthright, are entitled to the same education my parents struggled to give me access to. I believe that in the richest nation on earth, no one should go hungry. I believe in science. I believe in space travel. I believe in discovery for discovery’s sake. I believe in choice for every man and woman capable of making it. I believe that inaction is choice, too. I believe in a government that doesn’t regulate my thoughts, my ideals, or my actions unnecessarily. I believe it is only necessary when my pursuit of happiness jeopardizes someone else life or liberty. I believe in free speech, even for stupid people. (Though, I’ll say, I really believe we should educate the stupid out of them.) I believe in keeping what you earn and earning what you have.
Where does that leave me? Who does that make me? I am not a Democrat but I am not a Republican and I refuse to jump on the bandwagon of the self-defined Average Independent.
It’s a situation made all the more glaring by the people that I spend the majority of my time with. I work for a Fortune 500 company who manufactures heavy equipment in what I try to affectionately refer to as a “Purple” state. If you can imagine, the people drawn to work at such a place are former mechanics and farmers who enjoy spending their weekends downing cases of Miller and hunting. They spend their days chatting about their latest acquisition of fire power or newest brew. If you’re lucky, a handful will possess an Associates Degree, yet at least 50% have one DWI. They call themselves gun-toting rednecks and they wear that moniker like a badge of honor. Most of them are parents, many the single breadwinner, all barely scraping at the bottom of middle class (a number perilously close to the poverty line) and yet, if asked, each one of them would defend to the death their vote for a candidate that advocates tax breaks on corporations like the one that we work for…tax breaks that allow them to accrue (and deduct, I’m sure) $50,000 in travel expenses for a single mid-level manager in a six month period, jetting back and forth from my purple state to Italy. These people have children who will spend their lives in public schools and yet they advocate cutting teacher salaries. They place the product of our fisheries and forests on their tables and call dinner with the same breath that they advocate mining that will contaminate those precious streams and pieces of land.
They are, to me, the biggest contradiction. I grew up with staunch Republicans – truly middle class practitioners whose high six figure salaries were protected and directly grown by the Bush Tax Cuts. I understand them. I disagree fundamentally, but I understand them. To look at those people whose very families my approach to spending, government, taxes and politics would benefit most and have them fight me is perplexing and frustrating to say the least.
I find myself, a couple times a month, spilling over at these people with statements like “I don’t have kids but if and when I do they will have the same rarefied, private education that I was afforded because I am grateful for it every single day. I will never benefit from the system that I pay into but if asked tomorrow if I would contribute another percent of my hard-earned income to public schools, I would gladly volunteer and I would do it for your kid. Aren’t you supposed to be on this side of the argument?” (We’ll stay away from the fact that I regularly hear things like “If there’s a shoot out at the grocery store, damn it, I want my gun!” because the only response I ever seem to conjure is “We live two blocks apart – where the hell are you grocery shopping?“)
I believe that those of us who can should, and we should for the benefit for those who can’t and of those who weren’t afforded the resources. This year when, instead of a tax return, I get a bill from the IRS it will pain my cheap ass beyond measure to pay it, knowing that there are people in my life who don’t work for anything – their home, their clothes, their car payments, their Starbucks addiction and their take-out habit – who will get $10,000 or more in Federal refunds. In truth, I probably won’t be able to speak to them again until spring has turned into summer and they’ve blown through their free nest egg- on tanning, on cigarettes, on motorcycle payments and a new TV or another $700 dog – but I won’t vote for Rick Perry, Mitt Romney or our good buddy Newt in the 2012 election to rectify the situation either. Instead, I’ll write another letter, I’ll make another phone call, I’ll send another e-mail and I’ll urge my representatives in this Republic to close the loophole that allowed this laziness to fester and I’ll ask them to route that funding back into science and education and hope and dreams and I’ll wait for the next election cycle to figure out what it is that I am because the hope still lives, the work still goes on, the cause still endures and, for me at least, the dream shall never die.